JOSH McDOWELL
EVIDENCE
THAT DEMANDS A VERDICT
VOLUME IHISTORICAL EVIDENCES FOR THE CHRISTIAN FAITH
[KJV edition w/ Bible study links.]
Published by
[Evangelicals]1972, 1979 Campus Crusade for Christ, Inc.
Printed in the USAISBN 0-918956-46-3
Library of Congress No. 78-75041
FOREWORD Is Christianity credible?
Is there an intellectual basis for faith in Jesus Christ as the Son of God?
Scholars throughout the centuries, as well as millions of students and older
adults, would answer such questions with a resounding, "Yes!"
"Then saith he to Thomas, Reach hither thy finger, and behold my hands; and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into my side: and be not faithless, but believing.
And Thomas answered and said unto him, My Lord and my God.
Jesus saith unto him, Thomas, because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed." (John 20:27-29).
v
PREFACE There has been a definite shortage in the area of documentation of historical
evidences for the Christian faith. Often students, professors, and laymen have
asked, "How can we document and use what you and others teach?"DO WHAT WITH IT? It is my desire that these notes will help my brothers and sisters in Jesus Christ to
write term papers, give speeches and inject into classroom dialogues their
convictions about Christ, the Scriptures and the relevancy of Christianity in the
20th century.WATCH YOUR ATTITUDE The proper motivation behind the use of these lecture notes it to glorify and
magnify Jesus Christ -- not to win an argument.
vi
"But sanctify the Lord God in your hearts: and be ready always to give an
answer to every man that asketh you a reason of the hope that is in you
with meekness and fear:" (I Peter 3:15).WHY IN OUTLINE FORM? A LIFETIME INVESTMENT The following are books that I recommend a person buy for his library.
- Gle. Arc. A Survey of Old Testament Introduction. Moody Press.
- F. F. Bru. The Books and the Parchments. F. R.
- F. F. Bru. The New Testament Documents: Are They Reliable? I.-V.
Press.- Nor. L. Gei. and Wil. E. Nix. A General Introduction to the Bible.
Moody Press.- Car. Hen. (Ed.) Revelation and the Bible. B. B. House.
- K. A. Kit. Ancient Orient and Old Testament. I.-V. Press.
- Pau. Lit. Know Why You Believe. I.-V. Press.
- Joh. War. Mon. History and Christianity. I.-V. Press.
- Joh. War. Mon. Shapes of the Past. Edw. Bro.
vii
- Cla. Pin. Set Forth Your Case. C. Press.
- Ber. Ram. Pro. Christian Evidences. Moody Press.
- Wil. Smi. Therefore Stand. B. B. House.
- Peter Stoner. Science Speaks. Moody Press.
- Joh. Sto. Basic Christianity. I.-V. Press.
- Griffith Thomas. Christianity Is Christ. Moody Press.
WHO SAID IT? ...at the end of each section, the reader has
hundreds of documented sources that he can confidently use.
Working with me in compiling this research was a team of 11 students from nine
universities. .... (Since that time,
they have all graduated.)RESEARCH TEAM MEMBERS [...]
viii
EXPLANATION OF GENERAL FORMAT FOOTNOTES:
BIBLIOGRAPHY:
OUTLINE:
Method Used Here
1A. 1B. 1C. 1D. 1E. 1F.INDEXES:
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCHES: At the back of the book is a limited biography of
various authors. This will give the reader a background on some of the
authors quoted.
x
Chapter 6. JESUS--GOD'S SON .. 89
Chapter 7. THE TRILEMMA--LORD, LIAR OR LUNATIC? .. 103
Chapter 8. THE GREAT PROPOSITION .. 111
Chapter 9. THE MESSIANIC PROPHECIES OF THE OLD
TESTAMENT FULFILLED IN JESUS CHRIST .. 141Chapter 10. THE RESURRECTION--HOAX OR HISTORY? .. 179
SECTION III. GOD AT WORK IN HISTORY AND HUMAN LIVES .. 265
Chapter 11. PROPHECY FULFILLED IN HISTORY .. 267
Chapter 12. THE UNIQUENESS OF THE CHRISTIAN
EXPERIENCE .. 325
2
II Timothy 4:16
The manner in which the word "answer" is used in I Peter 3:15 denotes
"At my first answer no man stood with me, but all men forsook me: I pray God that it may not
be laid to their charge."
the kind of defense one would make to a police inquiry, "Why are you a
Christian?" A believer is responsible to give an adequate answer to that
question.2B. Christianity is a FACTual Religion
THE BEST DEFENSE IS A . . . 3B. Good Offense
3
HEBREWS 4:12 "For the word of God is quick, and powerful, and sharper than any twoedged
sword, piercing even to the dividing asunder of soul and spirit, and of the joints
and marrow, and is a discerner of the thoughts and intents of the heart."
We need a balance of the two above.... We must preach the
Gospel but also "be ready to give an answer of the hope that is in [us]."
The Holy Spirit will convict men of the truth; one does not have to be hit
over the head with it. "And a certain woman named Lydia, a seller of purple,
of the city of Thyatira, which worshipped God, heard us: whose heart
the Lord opened, that she attended unto the things which were spoken of Paul."
(Acts 16:14).2A. LET'S LAY SOME CONCRETE
Before one approaches the various evidences for the Christian faith, he
ought to have some misconceptions cleared up and understand several basic
facts.1B. Blind Faith
Christ commanded us to "...love the Lord thy God with all thy heart,
and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind" (Matthew 22:37).
4
.... The apostle
Paul said, "I know whom I have believed" (II Timothy 1:12). Jesus said,
"ye shall know [not ignore] the truth, and the truth shall make you free"
(John 8:32).2B. The Christian Faith Is an Objective Faith
(I Corinthians 15:14).
5
I SAW IT WITH MY OWN EYES 3B. Eyewitnesses
The writers of the New Testament either wrote as eyewitnesses of the
events they described or recorded eyewitness firsthand accounts of the
events.
II Peter 1:16
"For we have not followed cunningly devised fables, when we made known unto you
the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but were eyewitnesses
of his majesty."
6
EYEWITNESSES I John 1:1-3
Luke 1:1-3
Acts 1:1-3
I Corinthians 15:6-8
John 20:30,31
Acts 10:39-42
I Peter 5:1
8
[...]
9
... be the
personal word of I AM THAT I AM (Exodus 3:14).
10
Precaution: ....
I MUST BE BLIND 6B. Which Leap?
WILL THE REAL MR. EXCUSE PLEASE STAND UP? 7B. Intellectual Excuses
The rejection of Christ is often not so much of the "mind," but of the
"will"; not so much "I can't," but "I won't."
11
I have found that most people reject Christ for one or more of the
following reasons:Mic. Gre. cites Ald. Huxley, the atheist, who has....
- Ignorance -- Romans 1:18-23 (often self-imposed), Matthew 22:29
- Pride -- John 5:40-44
- Moral problem -- John 3:19,20
Ber. Russell is an ...atheist who did not give
careful examination to the evidence for Christianity.
12
John 7:17 assures one:
"If any man will do his will, he shall know of the doctrine,
whether it be of God, or whether I speak of myself."BIBLIOGRAPHY 1. ..., 1970.
[...]
22. ..., 1950.
13
section I __
the
Bible
-- I trust itThe purpose of this section is to build a working confidence in the Word of God.
The Bible is reliable and will stand up under a thorough examination.
15
chapter 1
the
uniqueness
of the
Bible1A. THE UNIQUENESS OF THE SCRIPTURE
1B. Introduction
2B. The Bible is Unique. It is the book "different from all others" in the
following ways (plus a multitude more):
16
1C. UNIQUE IN ITS CONTINUITY. Here is a book:
- Written over a 1,500 year span.
- Written over 40 generations.
- Written by over 40 authors from every walk of life including kings,
[...], etc.:
Moses, [...]
Paul, a rabbi- Written in different places:
- Written at different times:
- Written during different moods:
- Written on three continents:
Asia, Africa and Europe- Written in three languages:
Hebrew: Was the language of the O. T.
In II Kings 18:26-28 called....
In Isaiah 19:18 called....
Aramaic: Was the "common language" of the Near East until the
time of.... 32/218
Greek: N. T. language. Was the international language
at the time of Christ.- Its subject matter includes hundreds of ....
17
10. Conclusion of continuity -- a comparison with the Great Books of
the Western World.2C. UNIQUE IN ITS CIRCULATION
18
BIBLE PUBLICATION as of 1804
Date Bibles New Testament Portions
(Individual
books, etc.)
(Bri. Bib. Soc.)
in 1928
(Gid.s of Ame.)
(Nat. Bib. Soc.--Sco.)
(Dub. Bib. Soc.)
(Ger. Bib. Soc., 1927)
in 1930
(Ame. Bib. Soc.)
Others
in 1965
in 1966[Info only]
19
3C. UNIQUE IN ITS TRANSLATION
4C. UNIQUE IN ITS SURVIVAL
1D. Survival through time
20
2D. Survival through persecution
21
3D. Survival through criticism
22
5C. UNIQUE IN ITS TEACHINGS
1D. Prophecy
2D. History
From I Samuel through II Chronicles one finds the history of
23
Israel, covering about five centuries.
...in Genesis 10 is an....3D. Personalities
The Bible deals very frankly with the sins of its characters. Read
....
The sins of the people denounced -- Deuteronomy 9:24
Sins of the patriarchs -- Genesis 12:11-13; 49:5-7
... and the faults of the apostles --
Matthew 8:10-26; 26:31-56; Mark 6:52; 8:18; Luke 8:24,25;
9:40-45; John 10:6; 16:32
Disorder of the churches -- I Corinthians 1:11; 15:12;
II Corinthians 2:4; etc.6C. UNIQUE IN ITS INFLUENCE ON SURROUNDING LITERATURE
24
3B. The Conclusion Is Obvious
NOTE: The Bible is the first religious book to be taken into outer space
(it was on microfilm). It is the first book read describing the
source of the earth (astronauts read Genesis 1:1 -- "In the
beginning God...").
25
chapter 2
how
was the Bible
prepared?2A. PREPARATION OF THE SCRIPTURES
1B. Materials Used in Its Preparation
1C. WRITING MATERIAL
1D. Papyrus.
26
2D. Parchment.
3D. Vellum.
4D. Other writing materials
1E. Ostraca.
(Job 2:8).2E. Stones were inscribed on with an "iron pen[.]"
3E. Clay tablets were engraved
(Jeremiah 17:13;
Ezekiel 4:1).4E. Wax tablets.
2C. WRITING INSTRUMENTS
1D. Chisel.
2D. Metal Stylus.
3D. Pen.
(Jeremiah 8:8).4D. Ink was
27
2B. Forms of Ancient Books
1C. ROLLS OR SCROLLS.
(Revelation 5:1).2C. CODEX OR BOOK FORM.
3B. Types of Writing
1C. UNCIAL WRITING used upper case letters
2C. MINUSCULE WRITING was ....
4B. Divisions
1C. BOOKS (See page 30).
2C. CHAPTERS
The first divisions were made in 586 B.C. when the Pentateuch was
divided into 154 groupings (sedarim)
28
3C. VERSES. ...
were around 900 A.D.
29
chapter 3
the
canon3A. THE CANON
1B. Introduction
1C. MEANING OF THE WORD "CANON"
2C. TESTS OF A BOOK FOR INCLUSION IN THE CANON
- Is it authoritative -- did it come from the hand of God?
- Is it prophetic -- was it written by a man of God?
- Is it authentic?
- Is it dynamic -- did it come with the life-transforming power of God?
- Was it received, collected, read and used -- was it accepted by the
people of God?
Peter acknowledged Paul's work as Scripture parallel to Old
Testament Scripture (II Peter 3:16).2B. Old Testament Canon
1C. FACTORS DETERMINING NEED OF OLD TESTAMENT CANON
1D. The Jewish sacrificial system was ended by the destruction of
Jerusalem and the temple in 70 A.D. Even though the Old
30
Testament canon was settled in the Jewish mind long before....
2D. Christianity started to blossom and [...]
2C. THE HEBREW CANON
1D. The following is the breakdown of the Jewish Old Testament canon.
The Law
(Torah)
1. Genesis
2. Exodus
3. Leviticus
4. Numbers
5. DeuteronomyThe Writings
(Kethubhim or Hagiographa [GK])
A. Poetical Books
1. Psalms
2. Proverbs
3. JobThe Prophets (Nebhim)
A. Former Prophets
1. Joshua
2. Judges
3. Samuel
4. KingsB. Latter Prophets
1. Isaiah
2. Jeremiah
3. Ezekiel
4. The TwelveB. Five Rolls (Megilloth)
1. Song of Songs
2. Ruth
3. Lamentations
4. EcclesiastesC. Historical Books
1. Daniel
2. Ezra-Nehemiah
3. Chronicles3C. CHRIST'S WITNESS TO THE OLD TESTAMENT CANON
1D. Luke 24:44.
31
2D. John 10:31-36; Luke 24:44.
(Mark 7, Matthew 15), [...]3D. Luke 11:51 (also Matthew 23:35): [...]
(Genesis 4:8). [...]
(II Chronicles 24:21).4C. EXTRA-BIBLICAL WRITERS' TESTIMONIES
1D. of the book Ecclesiasticus (ca 130 B.C.).
2D. Josephus, the Jewish historian, (end of the first century A.D.)
writes:
[...]3D. The Talmud
1E. Tosefta Yadaim 3:5 says: "[...]; the books of Ben Sira
and whatever books have been written since his time are not
canonical."2E. Seder Olam Rabba 30 writes: [...]
3E. Babylonian Talmud, Tractate "Sanhedrin" VII- VIII, 24: [...]
4D. Melito, ..., drew up the oldest list of the Old
Testament canon that we can date (ca 170 A.D.).
Eusebius (Ecc. History IV.26) preserves his comments.
32
5D. ...is from the Mishnah (...).
5C. THE NEW TESTAMENT WITNESS TO THE OLD TESTAMENT AS
SACRED SCRIPTUREMatthew 21:42; 22:29; 26:54, 56
Luke 24
John 5:39; 10:35
Acts 17:2, 11; 18:28
Romans 1:2; 4:3; 9:17; 10:11; 11:2; 15:4; 16:26
I Corinthians 15:3,4
Galatians 3:8; 3:22; 4:30
I Timothy 5:18
II Timothy 3:16
II Peter 1:20,21; 3:16
[...] (John 7:38), ....6C. THE COUNCIL OF JAMNIA
33
7C. THE OLD TESTAMENT APOCRYPHAL LITERATURE
1D. Introduction
2D. Why not canonical?
Unger's Bible Dictionary:
- "They abound in historical and geographical inaccuracies and
anachronisms.
- "They teach doctrines which are false and foster practices which
are at variance with inspired Scripture.
- "They resort to [...]
- "They lack the distinctive elements which give genuine Scripture
their divine character, such as prophetic power and poetic and
religious feeling."3D. A summary of the individual books
[...]
35
[...]
4D. Historical testimony of their exclusion
- "Philo, Alexandrian Jewish philosopher (20 B.C.-A.D. 40), quoted
the O. T. prolifically and even....
- "Josephus (A.D. 30-100), Jewish historian, excludes the
Apocrypha, ....
- "Jesus and the New Testament writers never once quote the
Apocrypha although there are hundreds of quotes and references
to almost all of the canonical books of the Old Testament.
36
- "The Jewish scholars of Jamnia (A.D. 90) did not recognize the
Apocrypha.
- "No canon or council of the....
- "Many of the great fathers of...spoke out against
the Apocrypha, for example, Origen, ....
- "Jerome (340-420), a scholar and translator,
rejected the Apocrypha....
- "
- "
- "" 32/173
3B. The New Testament Canon
1C. TESTS FOR INCLUDING A BOOK IN THE NEW TESTAMENT
CANON
The basic factor for determining N. T. canonicity was
inspiration by God, and is chief test, apostolicity. 32/181
(Eph. 2:20)
(John 16:13)
(Acts 2:42).
(Gal. 1 and 2);
(I Cor. 14:37; cf. I Cor. 7:10)...." 88/117,118
37
2C. THE NEW TESTAMENT CANONICAL BOOKS
1D. Three reasons for a need to determine a New Testament canon:
1E. A heretic, Marcion (ca 140 A.D.), developed his own canon and
began to propagate it.2E. Many Eastern churches were using books in services that were
definitely....3E. Edict of Diocletian (A.D. 303) declared the destruction of the
sacred books of the Christians. ....2D. Athanasius of Alexandria (A.D. 367) gives us the earliest list of
New Testament books which is exactly like our present New
Testament.3D. ..., two writers, Jerome and Augustine,
define the canon of 27 books. 15/1124D. Polycarp (A.D. 115), Clement and others refer to the Old and New
Testament books with the phrase "as it is said in these scriptures."5D. Justin Martyr (A.D. 100-165), ...
6D. Irenaeus (A.D. 180)
7D. Ignatius (A.D. 50-115):
8D. The Church Councils.
38
3C. THE NEW TESTAMENT APOCRYPHA
32/200-205[...]
39
chapter 4
the
reliability
of the
BiblePART 1 -- Confirmation by Historical Text
4A. THE RELIABILITY AND TRUSTWORTHINESS OF SCRIPTURE
1B. Introduction
2B. The Bibliographical Test for the Reliability of the New Testament
1C. MANUSCRIPT EVIDENCE OF THE NEW TESTAMENT
There are now more than 5,300 known Greek manuscripts of the New
Testament. Add over 10,000 Latin ... and at least 9,300 other
early versions (MSS) and we have more than 24,000 manuscript copies
of portions of the New Testament in existence today.
41
2C. THE NEW TESTAMENT COMPARED WITH OTHER WORKS OF
ANTIQUITY1D. The manuscript comparison
43
2D. The textual comparison
WORK WHEN
WRITTENEARLIEST
COPYTIMESPAN NO. OF
COPIESHomer (Iliad) 900 B.C. 400 B.C. 500 yrs. 643 New Testament 40-100 A.D. 125 A.D. 25 yrs. over 24,000
46
3C. CHRONOLOGY OF IMPORTANT NEW TESTAMENT
MANUSCRIPTS48
4C. MANUSCRIPT RELIABILITY SUPPORTED BY VARIOUS
VERSIONS49
1D. Syriac versions
2D. Latin versions
52
6C. MANUSCRIPT RELIABILITY SUPPORTED BY LECTIONARIES
61
2C. PRIMARY SOURCE VALUE
They wrote as eyewitnesses or from first-hand information:
Luke 1:1-3 -- "Forasmuch as many have taken in hand to set forth in order a
declaration of those things which are most surely believed among us, Even as they delivered them unto us, which from
the beginning were eyewitnesses, and ministers of the word; It seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write
unto thee in order, most excellent Theophilus,"
II Peter 1:16 --
I John 1:3 --
Acts 2:22 --
John 19:35 --
Luke 3:1 --
Acts 26:24-26 --
62
(Acts 2:22).
3C. COMPETENT PRIMARY SOURCE MATERIAL
The New Testament must be regarded by scholars today as a
competent primary source document from the first century. 64/34,35CONSERVATIVE DATING
63
5B. External Evidence Test for Reliability of Scripture
1C. SUBSTANTIATING AUTHENTICITY
"Do other historical materials confirm or deny the internal testimony
provided by the documents themselves?" 64/312C. SUPPORTING EVIDENCE OF EXTRA-BIBLICAL AUTHORS
Eusebius, in his Ecclesiastical History III.39, preserves writings of
Papias, ... (130 A.D.) which Papias got from the
Elder (apostle John):
....Papias also comments about the Gospel of Matthew: ....
Irenæus, Bishop of Lyons (A.D. 180), who was a student of Polycarp,
Bishop of Smyrna; martyred in 156 A.D., had been a Christian for 86
years, and was a disciple of John the Apostle. He wrote:
....
64
...to John 13:25 and 21:20),
....Clement of Rome (ca A.D. 95) uses Scripture as being reliable and
authentic.Ignatius (A.D. 70-110). ... and was a disciple of
Polycarp, who was a disciple of the apostle John.
Elgin Moyer in ....
Ignatius gave credence to....Polycarp (A.D. 70-156) was a disciple of John and....
Flavius Josephus -- Jewish historian.
....
65
Tatian (ca A.D. 170) organized the Scriptures in order to put them in
the first "harmony of the Gospels" called the Diatessaron.Part 2 -- Confirmation by Archaeology
3C. EVIDENCE FROM ARCHAEOLOGY
68
1D. Ebla Kingdom proofs
2D. Old Testament examples of archaeological confirmation
69
1E. Genesis derives the ancestry of Israel from Mesopotamia.
2E. ... (Genesis 11:1) before the Tower of Babel. After
... (Genesis 11:9).3E. of Esau, ...
(Genesis 36:20).4E. of Jericho
Joshua 6:20 we read....5E. of Abraham
6E. of the Patriarchs
70
7E. Jul. Wel., a critic
8E. Henry M. Morris observes:
3D. New Testament examples
1E. Luke's reliability as a historian is unquestionable. Unger tells
us that....the birth of
Jesus (Luke 2:1-3).
(Acts
14:6).
72
(Luke 3:1)
Erastus (Romans 16:23).
debated in (Acts 18:4-7).
I Corinthians 10:25.
(Acts 19:23 ff.).
into the temple (Acts 21:28).
73
as the title for Gallio (Acts
18:12) is correct
(Acts 28:7).
of Thessalonica (Acts 17:6).2E. The Pavement.
(named, John 19:13).3E. The Pool of Bethesda, another site
CONCLUSION ...of the Scripture, I came to the
conclusion that it is historically trustworthy.
74
BIBLIOGRAPHY
- Bulletin of the Evangelical Theological Society. 1964. [p. 75]
- Encyclopaedia Britannica. 1970.
- Scripture Press Publications, 1969.
- Jewish Publications Society of America, 1969.
- Harvard Theological Review. 1928. [p. 76]
- Moody Press, 1898.
- Christianity Today. 1968.
- Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Co., 1946.
- The King's Business. 1949. [p. 77]
- Revelation and the Bible. 1969.
- Biblical Archaeologist Reader. 1961. [p. 78]